Gulf War: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
Line 3: Line 3:


The war was notable for the extremely high level of technology used by the Coalition, with lopsided victories in every tactical engagement. Coalition combat casualties were minimal, the number from [[fratricide]] and non-battle accidents comparable to those inflicted by the Iraqis. The war was also notable for not creating a clear peace, although the politics of the region prevented a replacement of the Hussein government.
The war was notable for the extremely high level of technology used by the Coalition, with lopsided victories in every tactical engagement. Coalition combat casualties were minimal, the number from [[fratricide]] and non-battle accidents comparable to those inflicted by the Iraqis. The war was also notable for not creating a clear peace, although the politics of the region prevented a replacement of the Hussein government.
==Background==
==Background==
Leading up to the Iraqi invasion was a period of brinksmanship and diplomatic miscommunication starting not long after the end of the [[Iran-Iraq War]].  
Leading up to the Iraqi invasion was a period of brinksmanship and diplomatic miscommunication starting not long after the end of the [[Iran-Iraq War]].  
Line 31: Line 29:
#Key point defense, operated by the [[Republican Guard]]
#Key point defense, operated by the [[Republican Guard]]
#Mobile, operated by the Iraqi Army
#Mobile, operated by the Iraqi Army
Iraqi air defense weapons and infrastructure were substantial,; their training and doctrine were the most limiting factors.<ref name=Vallance>{{citation
| title = Air Power in the Gulf War - The Conduct of Operations
| first = Andrew | last = Vallance
| publisher=Royal Air Force
| url = }}</ref>  The Iraqis began with:
*the KARI IADS
*roughly 7,000 SAMs
*10,000 anti-aircraft artillery (AAA) guns.
*Aircraft including Mirage F1, Su-24, MiG-25 and MiG-29
*twenty four very large and heavily fortified main operating bases and a further thirty major dispersal airfields. "virtually impossible to close for an extended period even with advanced weapons and large numbers of aircraft."
{| class="wikitable"
|-
! Category
! Quantity
! Type(s)
|-
| KARI [[IADS]]
| --
| French and Russian electronics, mostly Russian doctrine
|-
| [[surface-to-air missile]]s
| Approximately 7,000
| Soviet [[SA-2 GUIDELINE]], [[SA-3 GOA]], [[SA-5 GAMMON]], [[SA-6 GAINFUL]];
|-
| [[anti-aircraft artillery]]
| Approximately 10,000
| -
|-
| [[Fighter aircraft]]
|
| French [[Mirage F-1]]; Soviet [[MiG-25]],[[MiG-29]]
|}
If the Allied numerical superiority over the Iraqi air forces was very great, their technological superiority in terms both of platforms and weapons was even more marked. At the outbreak of hostilities, the technological level of Iraqi order of battle was variable. Although the Iraqis possessed advanced aircraft, perhaps half of their Air Force's front line consisted of variants of obsolescent MiG and Sukhoi designs.
(According to the IISS Military Balance 1990/1991 the Iraqi Air Force order of battle in Autumn 1989 consisted of two squadrons of bombers equipped with eight Tu-22s, four Tu-16s and four Chinese H-6Ds; Twenty two squadrons of fighter ground attack aircraft (equipped with ninety MiG-23BNs, sixty four Mirage F-1s, thirty Su-7s, seventy Su-20s, sixteen Su-24s and sixty Su-25s) and seventeen squadrons of air defence fighters (equipped with twenty five MiG-25s, forty J-7s, one hundred and fifty MiG-21s, thirty Mirage F-1s and thirty MiG-29s).
====Strategic====
====Strategic====
Early warning radars, at this level, included the [[SPOON REST radar|SPOON REST]], [[SQUAT EYE radar|SQUAT EYE]] and [[FLAT FACE radar]].
Early warning radars, at this level, included the [[SPOON REST radar|SPOON REST]], [[SQUAT EYE radar|SQUAT EYE]] and [[FLAT FACE radar]].
Line 37: Line 72:


==Defense of Saudi Arabia==
==Defense of Saudi Arabia==
Warden presented the original for the 1991 [[Gulf War]] air campaign to GEN (ret.) [[Chuck Horner]], then commanding air forces (CENTAF) for [[United States Central Command]]. According to a book by Horner (coauthored by [[Tom Clancy]]), a lieutenant general at the time, found he did not work well with Warden, and three stars beats one eagle.<ref name=ClancyHorner>{{citation | title =Every Man a Tiger: The Gulf War Air Campaign
It took negotiation at the highest levels before the Saudis agreed to have foreign troops in their country.
| first1 = Tom | last1 = Clancy |first2 = Chuck | last2 = Horner
 
| publisher = Putnam Adult
Once there was approval, the first units that arrived were [[United States Air Force]] [[F-15 Eagle]] air superiority fighters and [[E-3 Sentry]] early warning [[radar]] and air battle command post aircraft. The Saudis themselves operated versions of both aircraft types. There appears to have been initial surprise by the Saudis on the size of the ground support organization needed just for these aircraft.
| year = 1999}}</ref>  Sound thinking was involved, one member of the Checkmate. [[David Deptula]], teamed stayed in Saudi Arabia, and now is himself a lieutenant general, and Deputy Chief of Staff for [[C3I-ISR|Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance]], [[United States Air Force]].
 
[[Aircraft carrier]]s and warships capable of launching [[cruise missile]]s deployed to international waters. The first significant land forces unit was the U.S. [[82nd Airborne Division]]. The 82nd was variously called a tripwire, or, more cynically, a "speed bump", as a paratroop division could not have directly fought Iraqi armored units. Until U.S. armored units, such as the [[24th Infantry Division]] could arrive, the 82nd could only stay in light contact with Iraqi units, with carrier aircraft being the major weapon.
 
Had Saddam chosen to move immediately into Saudi Arabia, especially for a short distance, little could stop him until more forces arrived. His thinking has never really been explained.


The problems first seemed a matter of personalities. GEN [[H Norman Schwarzkopf Jr.]], commanding [[United States Central Command]] during the Gulf War, spoke well of Warden's original air war concepts.<ref name=Schwarzkopf>{{citation
| first = H Norman, Jr. | last = Schwarzkopf
| title = It Doesn't Take a Hero
| publisher = Bantam
| year = 1992}}</ref> Schwarzkopf did express concern that Warden saw the air component winning the war, and did not provide enough support to land forces.
==Attempts to prevent all-out hostilities==
==Attempts to prevent all-out hostilities==
Following the invasion, there were a number of diplomatic initiatives to find a peaceful solution, and hopes that the formation of what became a 34-nation coalition might give second thoughts to Saddam Hussein. <ref name=UNchron>{{citation
Following the invasion, there were a number of diplomatic initiatives to find a peaceful solution, and hopes that the formation of what became a 34-nation coalition might give second thoughts to Saddam Hussein. <ref name=UNchron>{{citation
Line 63: Line 96:


===Planning===
===Planning===
GEN Schwarzkopf asked for assistance in planning an air counterattack, and COL [[John Warden III]] presented the original draft concept for the 1991 [[Gulf War]] air campaign to GEN (ret.) [[Chuck Horner]], commanding Schwarzkopf's air component (CENTAF) for [[United States Central Command]]. According to a book by Horner (coauthored by [[Tom Clancy]]), Horner found his personality immediately clashed with Warden's, although there wee good ideas in the presentation. <ref name=ClancyHorner>{{citation | title =Every Man a Tiger: The Gulf War Air Campaign
| first1 = Tom | last1 = Clancy |first2 = Chuck | last2 = Horner
| publisher = Putnam Adult
| year = 1999}}</ref>  Sound thinking was involved, one member of the Checkmate. [[David Deptula]], teamed stayed in Saudi Arabia, and now is himself a lieutenant general, and Deputy Chief of Staff for [[C3I-ISR|Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance]], [[United States Air Force]].  Horner looked further for a compatible air operations planners, and selected [[Buster Glosson]].


The problems first seemed a matter of personalities. GEN [[H Norman Schwarzkopf Jr.]], commanding [[United States Central Command]] during the Gulf War, spoke well of Warden's original air war concepts.<ref name=Schwarzkopf>{{citation
| first = H Norman, Jr. | last = Schwarzkopf
| title = It Doesn't Take a Hero
| publisher = Bantam
| year = 1992}}</ref> Schwarzkopf did express concern that Warden saw the air component winning the war, and did not provide enough support to land forces.
===Initial strikes===
===Initial strikes===
By the time combat started, the Coalition had approximately 2,400 aircraft based either within the theatre of operations or close enough to be capable of projecting power into it. In contrast, the Iraqis had around 650.
Most of the initial air activity was aimed at [[suppression of enemy air defense]], disrupting the leadership and its communications, and WMD targets. The first shots to hit Iraq came from U.S. Army [[AH-64 Apache]] attack helicopters, led to an early warning radar station on the Saudi border by [[U.S. Air Force]] [[MH-53|MH-53 PAVE LOW]] special operations helicopters.
Most of the initial air activity was aimed at [[suppression of enemy air defense]], disrupting the leadership and its communications, and WMD targets. The first shots to hit Iraq came from U.S. Army [[AH-64 Apache]] attack helicopters, led to an early warning radar station on the Saudi border by [[U.S. Air Force]] [[MH-53|MH-53 PAVE LOW]] special operations helicopters.


With some limited exceptions on the outskirts, only [[stealth]] [[F-117]] aircraft flew into the Baghdad area, along with cruise missiles fired from ships and submarines in international waters, as well as from [[B-52]] bombers flying 36-hour round trip missions from their U.S. bases. Non-stealthy aircraft, however, ranged all over Iraq, simply avoiding the strongest air defenses in Baghdad.
With some limited exceptions on the outskirts, only [[stealth]] [[F-117]] aircraft flew into the Baghdad area, along with cruise missiles fired from ships and submarines in international waters, as well as from [[B-52]] bombers flying 36-hour round trip missions from their U.S. bases. Non-stealthy aircraft, however, ranged all over Iraq, simply avoiding the strongest air defenses in Baghdad.
Other than flying into the teeth of the Baghdad IADS, Coalition warplanes attacked all over Iraq and Kuwait, the Arab and Canadian pilots primarily in Kuwait alone. It may have seemed cheering to the Baghdad air defenders when they finally saw aircraft targets and turned on their targeting radars. What they were seeing, however, was a large proportion of all the drone aircraft in the U.S. Air Force and Navy inventory.  Once the fire control radars revealed themselves, large numbers of SEAD aircraft on the outskirts of Baghdad showered those radars with [[AGM-88 HARM]] [[anti-radiation missile]]s.


==Khafji: an attempted counteroffensive==
==Khafji: an attempted counteroffensive==

Revision as of 13:05, 3 July 2008

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
UNSC Resolutions [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

Formally beginning with the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait on August 2, 1990, and ending with the cease-fire on 6 April 1991, the Iraq War was preceded by the Iran-Iraq War, with tensions following that conflict's end in 1988, and followed by new tensions culminating with the U.S.-led Gulf War in 2003. The Gulf War involved the occupation of Kuwait and Kuwaiti resistance, the defense of Saudi Arabia by a growing coalition led by the United States, an intensive air campaign reducing Iraq's military, and a ground campaign that ejected the Iraqis and led to a cease-fire. Following the cease-fire was a period of interactions with a truculent Iraq, ensuring the elimination of its weapons of mass destruction and enforcing "no fly zones" in the North and South of Iraq. Eventually, Iraq was invaded in the 2003 Iraq War, with the disarming of the regular Iraqi military, the overthrow of Saddam Hussein's government, and an open-ended occupation and attempts at nation-building.

The war was notable for the extremely high level of technology used by the Coalition, with lopsided victories in every tactical engagement. Coalition combat casualties were minimal, the number from fratricide and non-battle accidents comparable to those inflicted by the Iraqis. The war was also notable for not creating a clear peace, although the politics of the region prevented a replacement of the Hussein government.

Background

Leading up to the Iraqi invasion was a period of brinksmanship and diplomatic miscommunication starting not long after the end of the Iran-Iraq War.

Hussein-Glaspie meetings

On July 25, 1990, U.S. Ambassador to Iraq, April Glaspie, met with Saddam Hussein. There are different accounts of whether Saddam was warned not to open hostilities, or if things could have been construed as the U.S. remaining neutral. Iraq had issued a transcript that suggested that the U.S. gave no strong warning. The New York Times reported that U.S. State Department issues, on receiving Glaspie's account, were unclear how strong a warning had been given, but that Administration sources said they did not want to make an issue of it at the time, because that might interfere with coalition-building. [1]

In the hearing, Representative Lee H. Hamilton, (Democrat, Indiana) the Ambassador if she had ever told Saddam that the U.S. would fight if Iraq invaded, and she said she did not explicitly do so. In response to Hamilton's question about his being deterred, she said: " I told him we would defend our vital interests. He complained to me for one hour about fleet movements and American neo-imperialism and militarism. He knew perfectly well what we were talking about, and it would have been absolutely wrong for me, without consulting with the President, to inform anybody of a change in our policy. Our policy was that we would defend our vital interests. It's up to the President to decide how we would do it. Saddam Hussein, who is a man who lives by the sword, believed that we were going to do it by the sword."

Specific indications of imminent invasion

U.S. intelligence moved to a specific attack warning on August 1. [2]

The Iraqi Government and Military

Iraq's civilian, security, and military apparatus was under the strongly centralized control of Saddam Hussein and his immediate circle, many of whom came from clansmen from Tikrit, Iraq. As such, Hussein was the center of gravity of the entire Iraqi structure.

KARI: Iraqi air defense

French Thomson-CSF had built what appeared to be an extensive integrated air defense system (IADS) for Iraq, called KARI[3]. The Iraqis, however, used it with a more Soviet doctrine that discouraged local decisionmaking.

The overall defense had three levels:

  1. National/strategic, operated by the Iraqi Air Force
  2. Key point defense, operated by the Republican Guard
  3. Mobile, operated by the Iraqi Army

Iraqi air defense weapons and infrastructure were substantial,; their training and doctrine were the most limiting factors.[4] The Iraqis began with:

  • the KARI IADS
  • roughly 7,000 SAMs
  • 10,000 anti-aircraft artillery (AAA) guns.
  • Aircraft including Mirage F1, Su-24, MiG-25 and MiG-29
  • twenty four very large and heavily fortified main operating bases and a further thirty major dispersal airfields. "virtually impossible to close for an extended period even with advanced weapons and large numbers of aircraft."
Category Quantity Type(s)
KARI IADS -- French and Russian electronics, mostly Russian doctrine
surface-to-air missiles Approximately 7,000 Soviet SA-2 GUIDELINE, SA-3 GOA, SA-5 GAMMON, SA-6 GAINFUL;
anti-aircraft artillery Approximately 10,000 -
Fighter aircraft French Mirage F-1; Soviet MiG-25,MiG-29

If the Allied numerical superiority over the Iraqi air forces was very great, their technological superiority in terms both of platforms and weapons was even more marked. At the outbreak of hostilities, the technological level of Iraqi order of battle was variable. Although the Iraqis possessed advanced aircraft, perhaps half of their Air Force's front line consisted of variants of obsolescent MiG and Sukhoi designs.

(According to the IISS Military Balance 1990/1991 the Iraqi Air Force order of battle in Autumn 1989 consisted of two squadrons of bombers equipped with eight Tu-22s, four Tu-16s and four Chinese H-6Ds; Twenty two squadrons of fighter ground attack aircraft (equipped with ninety MiG-23BNs, sixty four Mirage F-1s, thirty Su-7s, seventy Su-20s, sixteen Su-24s and sixty Su-25s) and seventeen squadrons of air defence fighters (equipped with twenty five MiG-25s, forty J-7s, one hundred and fifty MiG-21s, thirty Mirage F-1s and thirty MiG-29s).

Strategic

Early warning radars, at this level, included the SPOON REST, SQUAT EYE and FLAT FACE radar.

Iraqi invasion of Kuwait

air assault and armored movements

Defense of Saudi Arabia

It took negotiation at the highest levels before the Saudis agreed to have foreign troops in their country.

Once there was approval, the first units that arrived were United States Air Force F-15 Eagle air superiority fighters and E-3 Sentry early warning radar and air battle command post aircraft. The Saudis themselves operated versions of both aircraft types. There appears to have been initial surprise by the Saudis on the size of the ground support organization needed just for these aircraft.

Aircraft carriers and warships capable of launching cruise missiles deployed to international waters. The first significant land forces unit was the U.S. 82nd Airborne Division. The 82nd was variously called a tripwire, or, more cynically, a "speed bump", as a paratroop division could not have directly fought Iraqi armored units. Until U.S. armored units, such as the 24th Infantry Division could arrive, the 82nd could only stay in light contact with Iraqi units, with carrier aircraft being the major weapon.

Had Saddam chosen to move immediately into Saudi Arabia, especially for a short distance, little could stop him until more forces arrived. His thinking has never really been explained.

Attempts to prevent all-out hostilities

Following the invasion, there were a number of diplomatic initiatives to find a peaceful solution, and hopes that the formation of what became a 34-nation coalition might give second thoughts to Saddam Hussein. [5]

The United Nations, in an unprecedented way, had played a crucial role throughout the eight-month international crisis, which began on 2 August 1990 when Iraq invaded, occupied and annexed its neighbour--the tiny, oil-rich State of Kuwait--calling it an "integral part" of Iraq.

After the Iraqi invasion but before Coalition combat operations began, the UN Security Council, with majority votes, adopted 15 resolutions related to the crisis, among other things: condemning the initial invasion; calling for Iraqi troop withdrawal and protection of prisoners of war, diplomas and civilians; imposing strong, mandatory, comprehensive economic sanctions against Iraq until it complied with its demands; arranging for aid to innocent victims of the conflict and countries economically affected by the embargo; and setting a deadline before authorizing the use of "all necessary means" to restore international peace and security in the area.

The deadline passed. And a seven-week war took place--waged by a coalition of troops representing 34 nationalities--to oust Iraq from Kuwait.

Operations against Iraq

Planning

GEN Schwarzkopf asked for assistance in planning an air counterattack, and COL John Warden III presented the original draft concept for the 1991 Gulf War air campaign to GEN (ret.) Chuck Horner, commanding Schwarzkopf's air component (CENTAF) for United States Central Command. According to a book by Horner (coauthored by Tom Clancy), Horner found his personality immediately clashed with Warden's, although there wee good ideas in the presentation. [6] Sound thinking was involved, one member of the Checkmate. David Deptula, teamed stayed in Saudi Arabia, and now is himself a lieutenant general, and Deputy Chief of Staff for Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance, United States Air Force. Horner looked further for a compatible air operations planners, and selected Buster Glosson.

The problems first seemed a matter of personalities. GEN H Norman Schwarzkopf Jr., commanding United States Central Command during the Gulf War, spoke well of Warden's original air war concepts.[7] Schwarzkopf did express concern that Warden saw the air component winning the war, and did not provide enough support to land forces.

Initial strikes

By the time combat started, the Coalition had approximately 2,400 aircraft based either within the theatre of operations or close enough to be capable of projecting power into it. In contrast, the Iraqis had around 650.

Most of the initial air activity was aimed at suppression of enemy air defense, disrupting the leadership and its communications, and WMD targets. The first shots to hit Iraq came from U.S. Army AH-64 Apache attack helicopters, led to an early warning radar station on the Saudi border by U.S. Air Force MH-53 PAVE LOW special operations helicopters.

With some limited exceptions on the outskirts, only stealth F-117 aircraft flew into the Baghdad area, along with cruise missiles fired from ships and submarines in international waters, as well as from B-52 bombers flying 36-hour round trip missions from their U.S. bases. Non-stealthy aircraft, however, ranged all over Iraq, simply avoiding the strongest air defenses in Baghdad.

Other than flying into the teeth of the Baghdad IADS, Coalition warplanes attacked all over Iraq and Kuwait, the Arab and Canadian pilots primarily in Kuwait alone. It may have seemed cheering to the Baghdad air defenders when they finally saw aircraft targets and turned on their targeting radars. What they were seeing, however, was a large proportion of all the drone aircraft in the U.S. Air Force and Navy inventory. Once the fire control radars revealed themselves, large numbers of SEAD aircraft on the outskirts of Baghdad showered those radars with AGM-88 HARM anti-radiation missiles.

Khafji: an attempted counteroffensive

Liberation of Kuwait

Cease-fire and dispositions

References

  1. Friedman, Thomas L. (22 March 1991), "After the War; U.S. Explains View on Envoy to Iraq", New York Times
  2. Trainor, Michael R. (1995), The Generals' War: The Inside Story of the Conflict in the Gulf, Little, Brown
  3. The French word "Irak" spelled backwards
  4. Vallance, Andrew, Air Power in the Gulf War - The Conduct of Operations, Royal Air Force
  5. "War in Persian Gulf area ends; Iraq accepts UN cease-fire, demand for reparations, but calls Council resolution 'unjust.'", UN Chronicle, June, 1991
  6. Clancy, Tom & Chuck Horner (1999), Every Man a Tiger: The Gulf War Air Campaign, Putnam Adult
  7. Schwarzkopf, H Norman, Jr. (1992), It Doesn't Take a Hero, Bantam