Special operations: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
mNo edit summary
mNo edit summary
 
(6 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{PropDel}}<br><br>{{subpages}}
At a national policy level (i.e., all means of affecting other nations including military means), '''special operations''' produce effects in hostile, denied, or politically sensitive areas. Most often, they are conducted at the level of [[military doctrine|grand strategy or strategy]]. Sensitivities of the target often require the operation be [[clandestine operation|clandestine]] or [[covert operation|covert]].
At a national policy level (i.e., all means of affecting other nations including military means), '''special operations''' produce effects in hostile, denied, or politically sensitive areas. Most often, they are conducted at the level of military doctrine|grand strategy or strategy. Sensitivities of the target often require the operation be clandestine operation|clandestine or covert operation|covert.


Conventional military forces may support special operations, the special operation may be the only action by the government, or special operations may support conventional operations. They may involve joint action with foreign government or [[insurgency|insurgent]] forces. When they support conventional operations with such tasks as reconnaissance deep in enemy territory, or with raids to disable a key enemy capability, they become a [[force multiplier]].
Conventional military forces may support special operations, the special operation may be the only action by the government, or special operations may support conventional operations. They may involve joint action with foreign government or insurgent forces. When they support conventional operations with such tasks as reconnaissance deep in enemy territory, or with raids to disable a key enemy capability, they become a force multiplier.


Special operations differ from conventional operations
Special operations differ from conventional operations
Line 16: Line 16:


==Opportunities for ambiguity==
==Opportunities for ambiguity==
In most countries, '''special forces''' are the units that plan and execute such operations. This term is ambiguous in the United States, as [[United States Army Special Forces]] refers to specific kinds of units and doctrine for some, but not all, special operations; the more general U.S. term covers units under the [[United States Special Operations Command]].  
In most countries, '''special forces''' are the units that plan and execute such operations. This term is ambiguous in the United States, as United States Army Special Forces refers to specific kinds of units and doctrine for some, but not all, special operations; the more general U.S. term covers units under the United States Special Operations Command.  


In other countries, such as [[Iraq]] under [[Saddam Hussein]], or the [[Democratic People's Republic of Korea]] (North Korea),<ref name=DPRK-SF>{{citation
In other countries, such as Iraq under Saddam Hussein, or the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea),<ref name=DPRK-SF>{{citation
  | url = http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/dprk/1996/kpa-guide/part03.htm
  | url = http://www.globalsecurity.org/wmd/library/news/dprk/1996/kpa-guide/part03.htm
  | contribution = Part 3 - Special Operations
  | contribution = Part 3 - Special Operations
Line 26: Line 26:
}}</ref> "Special forces" refer to elite conventional forces. Another area of potential is that some military writers and organizations refer to conventional units using unusual movement skills, such as skis or mountain climbing, as "special operations".  
}}</ref> "Special forces" refer to elite conventional forces. Another area of potential is that some military writers and organizations refer to conventional units using unusual movement skills, such as skis or mountain climbing, as "special operations".  


True special operations forces almost always operate in units of small size, rarely in the hundreds in an operation, and usually in the tens. [[Operation Ivory Coast]], the U.S. attempt to rescue prisoners of war at the [[Son Tay]] prison in [[North Vietnam]],<ref name=Schlemmer>{{citation  
True special operations forces almost always operate in units of small size, rarely in the hundreds in an operation, and usually in the tens. Operation Ivory Coast, the U.S. attempt to rescue prisoners of war at the Son Tay prison in North Vietnam,<ref name=Schlemmer>{{citation  
  | title  = The Raid: The Son Tay Prison Rescue Mission  
  | title  = The Raid: The Son Tay Prison Rescue Mission  
  | first = Benjamin | last = Schlemmer
  | first = Benjamin | last = Schlemmer
  | year = 2002
  | year = 2002
  | publisher = Ballentine}}</ref> put 56 ground troops into the area, and had 92 airmen, including some helicopter crew on the ground, in the area of operations. Special reconnaissance teams often are made up of six soldiers. A guerrilla training and leadership unit can range from three (WWII [[Operation Jedburgh]]) to twelve ([[Special Operations Detachment A]]).
  | publisher = Ballentine}}</ref> put 56 ground troops into the area, and had 92 airmen, including some helicopter crew on the ground, in the area of operations. Special reconnaissance teams often are made up of six soldiers. A guerrilla training and leadership unit can range from three (WWII Operation Jedburgh) to twelve (Special Operations Detachment A).


The term "[[special operations forces]]" is least ambiguous.  Many nations use the term "operator" for the part of the force that directly fights the enemy or is behind enemy lines. Most special operations forces also need a substantial amount of specialized, often highly classified support. Some support operations may need to take place in the area of operations, but are lower-risk than direct combat or deep reconnaissance.<ref name=SFSG>{{citation |
The term "special operations forces" is least ambiguous.  Many nations use the term "operator" for the part of the force that directly fights the enemy or is behind enemy lines. Most special operations forces also need a substantial amount of specialized, often highly classified support. Some support operations may need to take place in the area of operations, but are lower-risk than direct combat or deep reconnaissance.<ref name=SFSG>{{citation |
  | url = http://www.eliteukforces.info/sfsg/
  | url = http://www.eliteukforces.info/sfsg/
  | title = Special Forces Support Group}}</ref>
  | title = Special Forces Support Group}}</ref>


There is a blurred line between military special operations forces and intelligence agencies that have a [[covert operation|covert action]] capability. Even more blurring can take place between [[clandestine human-source intelligence and covert action]] by personnel of the intelligence organization.
There is a blurred line between military special operations forces and intelligence agencies that have a covert operation|covert action capability. Even more blurring can take place between clandestine human-source intelligence and covert action by personnel of the intelligence organization.


Another blurry area include domestic law enforcement units that carry out police special operations (e.g., [[hostage]] negotiation and rescue), but may have [[counterterrorism]] missions. Some countries forbid their military to be used domestically, others use them only in very unusual cases, and yet others routinely use military special operations forces to carry out tasks beyond the capability of their [[police]].
Another blurry area include domestic law enforcement units that carry out police special operations (e.g., hostage negotiation and rescue), but may have counterterrorism missions. Some countries forbid their military to be used domestically, others use them only in very unusual cases, and yet others routinely use military special operations forces to carry out tasks beyond the capability of their police.


==Generally accepted true special operations missions==
==Generally accepted true special operations missions==
While special operations can trace back to the earliest military history, MAJ [[Robert Rogers]] and his Rangers, in the [[French and Indian War]], often is considered the ancestor of British and U.S. forces.  
While special operations can trace back to the earliest military history, MAJ Robert Rogers and his Rangers, in the French and Indian War, often is considered the ancestor of British and U.S. forces.  


*[[Guerrilla warfare]]
*Guerrilla warfare
*[[Raid]]s deep behind enemy lines, uniformed or not. Informally, many special operators call these "kick in the door" operations; a more formal term is [[direct action (military)]]
*Raids deep behind enemy lines, uniformed or not. Informally, many special operators call these "kick in the door" operations; a more formal term is direct action (military)
*[[Sniping]] and [[assassination]] behind enemy lines, possibly as part of a [[counterterrorism]] mission
*Sniping and assassination behind enemy lines, possibly as part of a counterterrorism mission
*[[Counterinsurgency]]
*Counterinsurgency
*[[Special reconnaissance]], using nonstandard ways to get in and out of the area of operations, and staying clandestine while operating
*Special reconnaissance, using nonstandard ways to get in and out of the area of operations, and staying clandestine while operating
*[[Psychological operations]], especially from behind enemy lines, but radio/TV broadcasts and leaflet drops can be part of a program. In some cases, special operations forces may help get radios, which only can receive their side's frequencies, and perhaps only need a crank for electrical power, to people in the area of operations
*Psychological operations, especially from behind enemy lines, but radio/TV broadcasts and leaflet drops can be part of a program. In some cases, special operations forces may help get radios, which only can receive their side's frequencies, and perhaps only need a crank for electrical power, to people in the area of operations


==References==
==References==
{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]

Latest revision as of 16:01, 20 October 2024

This article may be deleted soon.
To oppose or discuss a nomination, please go to CZ:Proposed for deletion and follow the instructions.

For the monthly nomination lists, see
Category:Articles for deletion.


This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

At a national policy level (i.e., all means of affecting other nations including military means), special operations produce effects in hostile, denied, or politically sensitive areas. Most often, they are conducted at the level of military doctrine|grand strategy or strategy. Sensitivities of the target often require the operation be clandestine operation|clandestine or covert operation|covert.

Conventional military forces may support special operations, the special operation may be the only action by the government, or special operations may support conventional operations. They may involve joint action with foreign government or insurgent forces. When they support conventional operations with such tasks as reconnaissance deep in enemy territory, or with raids to disable a key enemy capability, they become a force multiplier.

Special operations differ from conventional operations in degree of physical and political risk, operational techniques, mode of employment, independence from friendly support, and dependence on detailed operational intelligence and indigenous assets.[1]

Opportunities for ambiguity

In most countries, special forces are the units that plan and execute such operations. This term is ambiguous in the United States, as United States Army Special Forces refers to specific kinds of units and doctrine for some, but not all, special operations; the more general U.S. term covers units under the United States Special Operations Command.

In other countries, such as Iraq under Saddam Hussein, or the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea),[2] "Special forces" refer to elite conventional forces. Another area of potential is that some military writers and organizations refer to conventional units using unusual movement skills, such as skis or mountain climbing, as "special operations".

True special operations forces almost always operate in units of small size, rarely in the hundreds in an operation, and usually in the tens. Operation Ivory Coast, the U.S. attempt to rescue prisoners of war at the Son Tay prison in North Vietnam,[3] put 56 ground troops into the area, and had 92 airmen, including some helicopter crew on the ground, in the area of operations. Special reconnaissance teams often are made up of six soldiers. A guerrilla training and leadership unit can range from three (WWII Operation Jedburgh) to twelve (Special Operations Detachment A).

The term "special operations forces" is least ambiguous. Many nations use the term "operator" for the part of the force that directly fights the enemy or is behind enemy lines. Most special operations forces also need a substantial amount of specialized, often highly classified support. Some support operations may need to take place in the area of operations, but are lower-risk than direct combat or deep reconnaissance.[4]

There is a blurred line between military special operations forces and intelligence agencies that have a covert operation|covert action capability. Even more blurring can take place between clandestine human-source intelligence and covert action by personnel of the intelligence organization.

Another blurry area include domestic law enforcement units that carry out police special operations (e.g., hostage negotiation and rescue), but may have counterterrorism missions. Some countries forbid their military to be used domestically, others use them only in very unusual cases, and yet others routinely use military special operations forces to carry out tasks beyond the capability of their police.

Generally accepted true special operations missions

While special operations can trace back to the earliest military history, MAJ Robert Rogers and his Rangers, in the French and Indian War, often is considered the ancestor of British and U.S. forces.

  • Guerrilla warfare
  • Raids deep behind enemy lines, uniformed or not. Informally, many special operators call these "kick in the door" operations; a more formal term is direct action (military)
  • Sniping and assassination behind enemy lines, possibly as part of a counterterrorism mission
  • Counterinsurgency
  • Special reconnaissance, using nonstandard ways to get in and out of the area of operations, and staying clandestine while operating
  • Psychological operations, especially from behind enemy lines, but radio/TV broadcasts and leaflet drops can be part of a program. In some cases, special operations forces may help get radios, which only can receive their side's frequencies, and perhaps only need a crank for electrical power, to people in the area of operations

References

  1. US Department of Defense (12 July 2007), Joint Publication 1-02 Department of Defense Dictionary of Military and Associated Terms
  2. , Part 3 - Special Operations, North Korean People's Army Study Guide, GlobalSecurity.org, 1996
  3. Schlemmer, Benjamin (2002), The Raid: The Son Tay Prison Rescue Mission, Ballentine
  4. Special Forces Support Group